I have metamorphized in
so many ways since I first became an environmental studies student. I could
have never dreamed of how ENST could drastically change my perspective in the
way that it has. As Dr. Sarah Ray states in Affective
Ecocriticism Manuscript, “the ENST degree is [in some ways] some kind of
12-step program, with its own arc of affects, moving in stages from idealism,
lost innocence, shame, denial, grief, apathy, optimism, and then, I can only
hope, agency to work against diminution.” (Ray 1).
As I approach my last two semesters as an
undergraduate student, I can’t help but notice that I’ve gone through many of
these stages. Being an ENST student is perhaps the most emotionally taxing
major there is. A lot of people assume that it is an “easier” version of
environmental science, but I’d argue that in some ways it’s much more difficult.
Dr. Ray explains this when she writes, “students who choose ES because they
think it will be safe, feel-good, and easy are upset when they learn that
addressing environmental problems will require uncomfortable self-reflection,
not just learning how to argue better from established normative positions.”
(Ray 5). This certainly held true for me.
As Dr. Ray has pointed out, being aware of
the social aspects of environmental knowledge deeply challenges one’s belief
systems. I had never heard of the term, “environmental racism” until these past
few years. I used to believe environmentalists were most always aligned
with human rights activists, and it crushed me to find out about the many
controversies associated with environmentalism. The concept of conservation
refugees outraged me. I was heartbroken when I learned that environmentalists
kicked indigenous peoples out of their lands for the sake of conservation areas,
despite the fact that they were protecting their land on their own.
I used to think that all we needed to do
to “save the environment” was to participate in beach clean ups, recycle, eat
vegetarian, and perform simple daily tasks that help reduce our impact on the
planet. While I still believe that it’s important to do these things, I was
crushed to find out that on its own, it is simply not enough. Globally
speaking, we are going to need to go through a major transformative shift that
involves reducing consumption rates while still protecting the rights of
humans. Sometimes, that seems impossible, but its better to know the ugly truth
than to hide in the bliss of ignorance. I went into this major having “drunk
the dying-polar-bears Kool-Aid,” only to find out that it is much more
complicated than that.
Dr. Ray points out that, “The
environmental justice approach shifts students’ frames of “the problem” away
from a blaming-the-victim approach toward an understanding of structural
injustice” (Ray 8). Understanding environmental justice has certainly changed
my perspective. I used to believe that much of the environmental damage across
the globe came from misuse of the land in developing nations. While in some
cases this is true, it’s usually a result of multinational corporations from
countries like the United States exploiting other countries lands in ways that
hardly benefit the natives. ENST has given me a perspective on environmental
justice that hadn’t occurred to me before.
Now that I have entered the service learning
part of my undergraduate degree, I plan to use what I’ve learned in ENST to
deconstruct the value of my work and make it a critical service learning project. I have learned about the dark
past of environmentalism, as well as the importance of social justice, and I hope
that I can use this knowledge to offer something unique to my project with
Redwood State Parks. Environmental Studies gave me a very bleak outlook on our
future for quite some time, but I’m finally starting to move forward with hope
that we can use a transformative approach to create a better world.
cat- it's really fantastic to see into your thinking through the lens of these readings and conversations.
ReplyDelete